Scotch Broom Ecological Impact Study

SB_ElkCreek_JohnGussman.PNG

“Scotch broom excludes native vegetation through competition, alters soil nutrient availability, and reduces mycorrhizal fungi associated with native plants. These soil legacies can persist following Scotch broom removal and inhibit native plant establishment."

-Dr. Sara Grove, University of California, Santa Cruz

Study Questions

  1. Is Scotch broom arresting the succession of riparian communities?

  2. What factors are limiting riparian plant establishment and growth in areas where Scotch broom occurs?

  3. Do changes in soil properties that result from Scotch broom invasion persist as soil legacies following removal?

  4. Do soil legacy effects of Scotch broom limit riparian plant establishment and success?

Field Transplant Experiment

We are evaluating how non-native Scotch broom effects the establishment of native riparian plant seedlings along the Hoh River, located on the coast of Washington State’s Olympic Peninsula. We hypothesize that where Scotch broom occurs, the combined effects of direct competition and changes to the abiotic and biotic soil environment will reduce the survival and growth of native riparian seedlings. We further predict that the changes to the soil will persist following Scotch broom removal and continue to have suppressive effects on native riparian plant establishment, even in the absence of Scotch broom competition. To test these hypotheses we planted red alder, willow, and black cottonwood into areas where Scotch broom 1) has invaded and remains intact, 2) has invaded and been removed, or 3) does not occur.

In 2019, we installed 180 plots in two riparian sites in the Hoh watershed (N = 60 plots/treatment/site). From within the watershed, we collected red alder, willow, and black cottonwood, seedlings, and planted five of each species into each plot. Each seedling was tagged and measured at the time of planting. In the summer of 2020, we measured seedling survival and growth.

10KYI_SBImpactStudy_ElkCreekFloodplain_Tagging_Measuring_2019129to10+%2814%29.jpg
10KYI_SBImpactStudy_%2BBakerBar_AfterTreatment_10.12.2019.jpg

Competitor Exclusion Experiment

Scotch broom can invade areas where native riparian vegetation is already present. To understand how Scotch broom limits the success of mature riparian plants, we have instigated a competitor removal experiment. We predict that Scotch broom outcompetes native plants for limiting resources, particularly water during the summer months; and that Scotch broom removal will result in increased survival and growth rates of riparian plants. To test this prediction we identified, marked, and measured 80 established red alder and willow plants across three sites within the Hoh watershed. We removed all adjacent Scotch broom from around half of these riparian plants. After the first growing season, we measured the survival and growth of the riparian plants, and will use this data to compare riparian plant performance with and without adjacent Scotch broom.

Mycorrhizal Mutualism Disruption Plant-Soil Feedback Experiment

Invasive species can alter the soil microbial communities in ways that inhibit native plants. We hypothesize the Scotch broom may reduce the abundance of ectomycorrhizal fungi that provide important benefit to native riparian plants. To test this idea, we used soils collected from Scotch broom invaded areas and nearby uninvaded areas in a plant-soil feedback greenhouse experiment. We have planted willow and cottonwood stakes and alder seedlings into their own soils and invaded soils, and will compare plant survival, growth, and the abundance of ectomycorrhizal fungi occurring on the riparian plant roots.

20200310_102108.jpg

Check back soon for more updates and results for all of these exciting studies!